14 May 2018

Uber Drivers take a day off to highlight low pay

From Nine To Noon, 9:31 am on 14 May 2018

Some Uber drivers around the country are protesting today against low pay and the structure of the company.

Some Uber drivers opted to go out of action on 14 May, 2018 to protest against the low pay they received

Some Uber drivers opted to go out of action on 14 May, 2018 to protest against the low pay they received Photo: RNZ

Sher Abid - the organiser of the action on Uber from the Rideshare Drivers Network, which represents ride-share apps -  told Nine to Noon the 'Uber Driver Day Off' aimed to bring to light the concerns Uber drivers face, such as low pay.

Drivers ended up with less than the minimum wage because costs, like petrol, were taken out of their own pocket and about 25-28 percent of their earnings went to the company, Mr Abid said.

However, an Uber spokesperson said that the feedback they recieved from the drivers about earnings and other issues were being dealt with in various ways.

Sher Abid from the Rideshare Drivers Network, which represents ride-share apps, was the organiser of the action on Uber on 14 May, 2018.

Sher Abid from the Rideshare Drivers Network, which represents ride-share apps, was the organiser of the action on Uber on 14 May, 2018. Photo: RNZ

"Earnings vary depending on when driver-partners choose to use the app, and the vehicle they choose to drive," the spokesperson said.

"We have introduced a number of initiatives in recent months following their feedback.

"This includes paid wait time, ratings protection features and fuel discounts via a partnership with BP, which accompanies other partner benefits via our Momentum program such as vehicle maintenance and financial management assistance."

Out of 6000 registered drivers around the country, only 100 were expected to take part in today's action. Mr Abid some drivers were reluctant to strike because they could be dropped from the app without warning.

"It has happened many times that people were actually kicked off the app because of costumer complaints about them or for any other reason... [Uber] will be spy on social media groups and if any driver is saying anything against Uber they'd just kick him off," he said.

Wellington Uber drivers want the company to change its policies and reduce the commission taken by the company to 10 percent, Mr Abid said.

He said the self-employment status of the drivers, known as partners, was part of the company's structure that was causing concern because Uber was not obliged to make sure they were paid above minimum wage.

Another concern for drivers was whether Uber was paying tax on their behalf out of the 25-28 percent cut they take, Mr Abid said.

Those who pay 28 percent of their earnings to the company believed Uber was paying the tax on their behalf, but with nothing in writing, were worried what would happen if they were contacted by IRD.

"The tax structure is not really organised we need more education and clear instructions on tax," Mr Abid said.

The confusion with regards to insurance on accidents was similar, Mr Abid said.

"Uber says we only need personal insurance but there have been cases that someone had insurance on their car and they had an accident and Uber never came back to them," he said.

So in some cases drivers were left out of pocket, Mr Abid said, but according to the law the drivers need commercial insurance.

Some Uber drivers took to the streets to protest against what they say are unclear policies in the company which has left them out pocket.

Some Uber drivers took to the streets to protest against what they say are unclear policies in the company which has left them out pocket. Photo: RNZ

The network has tried to contact Uber about their concerns but have not had any luck, because most of the communication took place via email or the app itself.

According to Uber's spokesperson, the company holds regular driver-partner events to engage our driver-partner community and offers a number of ways for driver-partners to engage with the business locally. 

This includes: 

  •  Regular roundtables to consult on app changes and elicit feedback
  • Opened a new, expanded Greenlight Hub (partner support centre) in Kingsland in Auckland in December 2017, and also have centres in Wellington and Christchurch where driver-partners can speak to local Uber representatives
  • Driver-partner events, such as a Movie Night for driver-partners and their families in February plus International Women's Day breakfasts in March
  • Phone and in-app support - feedback channels that are open 24/7 where driver-partners can contact Uber for any questions or concerns

Employment lawyer Susan Hornsby -Geluk said on the face of it the drivers couldn't get the benefits of being employed.

"Uber says that these people are independent contractors. That means they have no minimum rights, no rights to minimum rates of pay, no leave entitlements or any of the other protections that employees do get."

However she said courts overseas had disagreed with that based on the amount of control drivers had over their job.

"In the UK they have found that Uber drivers are employees not contractors and I would expect sooner rather than later there'll be similar cases in both Australia and New Zealand.

"The Uber drivers would have to take a case to the Employment Relations Authority claiming that they were in fact employees because the label on their contract, namely that they're independent contractors, does not reflect the true nature of that relationship."

Ms Hornsby-Geluk said legislative changes promised by the Labour government could also provide some reprieve.

"The Labour Party have foreshadowed that they're intending to introduce greater protections for what they're describing as 'dependent contractors'.

"The uber drivers are probably the very types of employees that might fall into that category where there's a strong level of control by the contracting agent.

She said if that did happen it could mean minimum wage and leave entitlements for drivers.