18 Jan 2023

Elon Musk faces trial over Tesla tweet that could see him pay billions in damages

6:38 am on 18 January 2023
US entrepreneur and business magnate Elon Musk gestures during a visit at the Tesla Gigafactory plant under construction, on August 13, 2021 in Gruenheide near Berlin, eastern Germany. (Photo by Patrick Pleul / POOL / AFP)

If a San Francisco jury rules in the shareholder's favour, Elon Musk may be ordered to pay billions of dollars in damages. Photo: AFP

A trial into a tweet by Elon Musk alleging that he would take Tesla private in a $US72 billion ($112b) buyout is set to begin on Tuesday (US time).

Musk is being sued by Tesla shareholders, who say that he manipulated the share price of the company.

In 2018, he tweeted that he had "funding secured" to take the car maker private.

However, the funding was not secured - and Tesla was not taken private.

Shareholders argued they lost billions of dollars due to the tweet after the share price plummeted.

The Tesla chief executive, however, argued that he believed he had secured funding from Saudi Arabia's Investment Fund, and did not commit securities fraud.

If a San Francisco jury rules in the shareholder's favour, Musk may be ordered to pay billions of dollars in damages.

He has already paid $20m to the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) for the 7 August 2018 tweet, while Tesla had to pay another $20m.

The SEC also removed Musk as chairman of Tesla as a result of the tweet.

His tweet has become legendary in Silicon Valley, as it showed the sheer power that 140 characters on Twitter can have.

Legal experts said they believed it would be a difficult case for Musk to win, and that the fine he paid to the SEC would be used against him in the case. However, jury trials in cases of fraud are notoriously difficult to predict.

Musk had wanted the trial to be moved to Texas, arguing a fair jury would not be possible to find in San Francisco.

He argued that mass sackings at Twitter, a company he bought last year, affected many employees in San Francisco - and that he is not popular in the city.

Musk's team had argued that a significant majority of potential jurors said they viewed the billionaire negatively.

However, the judge said the trial would go ahead in California.

The trial may see Musk give evidence under oath. The witness list also includes Oracle's chief executive Larry Ellison and media tycoon James Murdoch.

-BBC

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs